theProGunDemocrat.com "…where we support ALL the Amendments"

Trump Continues to Lose Support from His White House Team, Including Mike Pence

Unlike Trump, Biden Delivers on Infrastructure Promise - updated

For Political Reasons, Trump Bullies GOP into Opposing Bipartisan Border Solution

Job Growth Under Biden Continues to Out-Perform Expectations - updated

GOP-Leaning States Have Highest Gun Violence - Some More Than Chicago

2023 Vote: Dems, Choice, & Democracy Continue to Do Well

EV Battery Life Longer than Thought

Construction of U.S. Factories is Booming Under Biden

Did Trump Even Steal His MAGA Slogan? From Bill Clinton?

Democrats Are Delivering for Michigan...So GOP Tries Recall

Expanding Medicaid Helps Rural America -- N.C. Signs Up, But When Will Mississippi?

Boebert Embarasses Herself Again - This Time On Public Urination

Alex Jones Found Guilty of Sandy Hook Lies - Owes Plaintiffs $980m

2022: What Red Wave? GOP Barely Wins House, Dems/Freedom/Democracy Prevail Elsewhere

Trump Takes the Fifth in Criminal Investigation

America Approves of Schumer-Manchin Bill, But GOP Still Votes No

CIA Kills Zawahiri, 9/11 Mastermind

Did Gorsuch & Kavanaugh Lie to Congress about Roe vs. Wade?

Oil Execs Blame Wall Street for High Gas Prices, They Don't Blame Biden

Biden Isn't Messing Around on Cybersecurity - updated

Biden/Blinken Rally NATO to Support Ukraine; Entire World Condemns Putin...Except Trump & Fox - updated

Study: Trump's Trade War a Failure

Best Stock Market Results One Year After Election Belongs to...Joe Biden

Fox News Covid Policy for Employees: Get Vaccinated or Get Tested Daily

FDA Fully Approves Covid Vaccine - No More Excuses?

Former CPAC Head Says GOP Now a Cult: They Wouldn't Even Elect Reagan

Dems Pass Biden's Covid Relief Bill; GOP Votes No

Trump Encourages Seditious Mob, Won't Stop Violence, Gets Impeached

Biden Wins Presidency; Trump Pouts, Promotes Baseless Fraud Conspiracies

FBI Director Says White Supremacists are Biggest US Terror Threat, Russia is Helping Trump, No Signs of Voter Fraud

Sorry, Trump Dislikes Our Veterans

Biden Won't Defund the Police, but Trump's Budget Does

Biden Helped Save the U.S. Auto Industry, but Pence Voted No

Will GOP Ever Fix Our Infrastructure?

Even Trump's Sister Disses Him

Lincoln Project's Ads Skewer Trump

GOP's Perdue Was Proud to Send American Jobs to China

Eric Cantor Calls Joe Biden 'Awesome'

Powerful Long-Time Lindsey Graham Supporter Says "Not This Year"

Trump Culture of Hate Trickles Down in GOP: AOC Accosted on Capitol Steps

Was Breaking Up a Peaceful Protest to Stage a Photo Op the Last Straw?

Bush Calls for Unity During Pandemic, but Trump Tries to Pick a Fight

Clint Eastwood Endorses Bloomberg

Mayor Pete's Health Plan Saves $'s

GOP, Conservatives, Evangelicals Who Support Trump Impeachment

Trump Foundation Shut Down by NY Atty Genl for Illegal Actions - updated

2019 Elections: Dems Take Virginia Assembly, KY & Louisiana Guv Races

What? Fox's Tucker Carlson Likes Elizabeth Warren's Economic Plan?

Is this why Jerry Falwell Jr. Endorsed Trump?

Eric Cantor Calls Joe Biden 'Awesome'

Beto Pays El Paso, Trump Doesn't

Kentucky GOP Chickens Out: Uninvites AOC to Coal Country

Reagan's Budget Chief Calls Trump "Unhinged Madman"

Trump Insults Allies, Cozies Up to Communist Dictator, and Gets Played...Again

Even Fox Calls Out Trump's Lies About the Mexican Border Wall

George H. W. Bush: A Retrospective

2018 Blue Wave: Dems, Min Wage, Healthcare, Democracy Win Big

Don't Look Now, But Trump Doesn't Like Southerners Either

Right-to-Work Defeated by Missouri Voters - Bigly!

Russian Hackers Penetrate U.S. Power Grid

Is "Medicare for All" Gaining Momentum? - updated

Anti-Immigrant Activists Should Check Their Own Family History First

Trump Tries Claiming He Can Pardon Himself - Why, Unless He's Guilty?

Tillerson's Concerns About Truth & Ethics Seen as Swipe at Trump

Uh-oh: Carter Draws Bigger Crowd than Trump at Liberty Commencement

Will Agriculture Pay the Price for Trump's Trade War?

Tillerson Fired Via Tweet - Weak!! (Was Russia the Tipping Point?)

Kochs Contribute $500k to Paul Ryan After Tax Bill Passes

Missouri Gov. Greitens Admits Affair - Will Evangelicals Still Support Him?

Gates, Buffett, & Now Bloomberg Have Doubts About Trump Tax Plan

"Deal Maker" Trump Botches Another Opportunity: This Time It's Jerusalem

Bannon Loves Roy Moore, But Why Does the Senate GOP?

2017 Election Results: Dems Win Big

Starting Day 1, Trump Already Hurting Many Who Voted For Him - updated

Arpaio Pardon Shows Trump's Contempt for Rule of Law

Even GOP Leaders Criticize Trump Comments on Va Violence

Fox Downplays Story of Iowa Cop Killer Who Backed Trump

ACA Helping to Reduce Bankruptcies

House GOP Rejects "Buy American" Provisions

McConnell Admits (Sort of) that Coal Jobs Aren't Coming Back - Now What?

ARCHIVE - News Briefs

Lyin' Donald Trump?

Right Wing Myth-Busting

Gates, Buffett, & Now Bloomberg Have Doubts About Trump Tax Plan

GOP Elders Propose Carbon Tax to Fight Climate Change

Overtime Change Will Boost Middle Class Wages

Buffett's Anti-Poverty Program (Reagan Supported It Too)

The Federal Deficit Was Shrinking

Study Shows Auto Bailout a Success

The Conservative Case FOR a Higher Minimum Wage

How Bush Sr. Solved Acid Rain Using Basic Economics

The National Debt and Federal Fiscal Policy

Thoughts on the Wall Street Bailout

ARCHIVE - Economics

Political Cartoons & Memes

Kochs Contribute $500k to Paul Ryan After Tax Bill Passes

Bannon Loves Roy Moore, But Why Does the Senate GOP?

2017 Election Results: Dems Win Big

House GOP Rejects "Buy American" Provisions

NC GOP Continues Power Grab

KKK Victory Parade for Trump

Clinton Wins Popular Vote; Other Election Results

Benghazi Not Clinton's Fault Says Stevens Family

List of Republicans Not Supporting Donald Trump Continues to Grow

When Will Republicans Agree to Fix Our Nation's Infrastructure?

McConnell and GOP Block Student Loan Re-financing Bill

Mitt Romney Makes Anti-Trump Case

Pro-Gun Democrat Edwards Wins Louisiana Governor's Race

Montana & Alaska Beat Back Far Right to Expand Medicaid

What Happened to the Ebola Crisis?

Eric Cantor Calls Joe Biden 'Awesome'

Another GOP Candidate who Made his Money Sending US Jobs Overseas

Even Conservatives Think the GOP is Sabotaging the Economy

ARCHIVE - Politics

Upcoming Gun & Militaria Shows

O'Reilly & Trump Favor New Gun Control Legislation

The GOP & Guns

Our Favorite Pro-Gun Democrats

Snyder Vetoes Gun Rights in Michigan

Is Single-Payer Gaining Momentum?

ACA Helping to Reduce Bankruptcies

Unpaid Hospital Bills Fall as ACA Expands

Five Reasons We Like the ACA

Obamacare: The GOP Was For It, Before They Were Against It

Don't Believe These Lies About the Affordable Care Act

ARCHIVE - Healthcare

Arpaio Pardon Shows Trump's Contempt for Rule of Law

Minimum Wage Increases Upheld by Missouri, Arizona Supreme Courts

Can the President Appoint Garland if the Senate Won't Act?

Oklahoma, Nebraska Want to Disallow Part of Colorado's Marijuana Law

Has the Supreme Court Legalized Political Bribery?

Tillerson Fired Via Tweet - Weak!! (Was Russia the Tipping Point?)

"Deal Maker" Trump Botches Another Opportunity: This Time It's Jerusalem

How to Deal with Russia

Are Obama/Kerry Right About the Middle East?

House GOP Panel Admits Benghazi Rumors are Not True

Religion and Politics

Missouri Gov. Greitens Admits Affair - Will Evangelicals Still Support Him?

Christian Groups' Christian Response to Syrian Refugees

Can This Company Reverse Climate Change?

Update on Other Alternative Energies

Fracking Viable Thanks to...the Feds?

All-Time Best NFL Helmets: Rankings

Did Trump's Greed/Mismanagement Cause the USFL to Fold?

Bernie & the NFL: Two Peas in a Socialist Pod?

Big10 Football: Are "Experts" Changing their Tune?

Is Hardy Signing Another Reason for Fans to Dislike the Dallas Cowboys?

Gronk Handles a Trash-Talker

How Bush Sr. Solved Acid Rain with Basic Economics


January 2016 - If you're old enough to remember the 1980's, you may remember hearing people talk about acid rain, one of the major environmental issues of the time. And for those of you who admit to having forgotten about it, your forgetfulness probably is because an overwhelmingly bi-partisan majority in Congress, working in conjunction with President George H. W. Bush (Bush Sr.), passed unique legislation that solved the problem in less than 20 years. What follows is a brief recap of that success story.


North America's acid rain problem emanated in the American West and Midwest, where coal-fired power plants were discharging vast clouds of sulfur dioxide into the atmosphere. This sulfur dioxide was drifting eastward and falling back to earth in the form of acid rain, damaging lakes, forests, buildings, and human health across eastern Canada and the eastern United States. This was a classic case of an industry generating what economists call "external costs", where the industry created costs that they themselves (and, in this case, their consumers also) were able to avoid, but that others were forced to pay.


(Image from Forbes)

Consequently, a combination of citizens in eastern North America plus a number of environmental groups were proposing that regulations be put in place to force the guilty power plants to limit their sulfur emissions. But these proposals were going nowhere: the proposals typically mandated specific approaches to achieve the reductions; the utility industry balked at what they felt were the inflexibility of these regulations, plus what they felt would be the exorbitant costs to implement any of the solutions; and the Reagan administration, not particularly friendly to environmental concerns, refused to broker a compromise.


By the late 1980's, though, George Bush Sr. was in the White House. He had campaigned on addressing environmental issues, specifically acid rain, and was looking for a solution. At the same time, the seemingly unlikely combination of some open-minded environmentalists and some concerned free-market conservatives were floating the idea of a market-based approach to the issue: put a limit on each power plant's sulfur dioxide emissions, but don't tell the utilities how to achieve those reductions. Impose stiff penalties for those who exceeded their limit but, and here is the particularly unique economic approach being floated, consider those limits as being "allowances to emit" and let the utilities buy and sell these allowances among themselves. The allowances would thereby become a commodity that could be traded in the marketplace.


What this approach would do is allow each power plant's management to innovate as they saw fit and to find their own least expensive means of lowering their sulfur dioxide emissions. They could look into using low sulphur coal, or consider installing scrubbers to clean their discharged smoke, or they could even increase their allowed emissions by purchasing allowances from other utilities. Of course, those allowances would only be available if another plant's emissions fell below their own allowance. In total, then, the industry as a whole still would be meeting the overall emission guidelines. The allowance system also allowed for the banking of unused allowances, so a utility could save them for the future if they chose not to earn more revenue by selling them in the current year.


This new approach was included in the Clean Air Act of 1990 and, while initially described as "emissions trading", it soon became known as "cap and trade": "Cap" emissions and allow utilities to "trade" their allowances, or credits.


(Bush signing Clean Air Act - image from epa.gov)


Working with Congress, the Bush Sr. administration decided to establish an initial 10 million ton reduction in sulfur dioxide emissions, which would decrease those sulfur discharges from a level of 26 million tons annually to 16 million tons. Over time, that target level would fall to 8.95 million tons, thereby making the program's allowances even more valuable and encouraging more innovation on the part of the utilities.


Many environmentalists questioned this approach, some believing it was a license to pollute and others feeling that it abrogated the role of regulators. Many industry leaders expressed concern about buying and selling the allowances ("Is there value in these pieces of paper?") and estimated that achieving the prescribed reductions would end up costing between $5 billion and $25 billion a year. The Environmental Protection Agency estimated these costs at $6.1 billion.


So, jumping to the bottom line, what were the results of this innovative approach? Did it actually work? Well, once the federal government got the ball rolling by buying allowances for its Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) electricity provider, the industry never looked back. By 2004, sulfur dioxide emissions had fallen 36%, while power output had increased by 25%. Three years later, the 8.95 million ton cap was reached and three years after that, emissions were down to 5.1 million tons. Cost-wise, industry and independent researchers in 1998 put the price tag for implementation at between $1 billion and $2 billion dollars; a recent study put it at $3 billion a year, while achieving benefits of $122 billion a year.


With such a success, it's not surprising that Europe and the state of California have adopted similar programs to begin reducing their carbon dioxide output, a primary contributor many scientists have identified behind the earth's rising temperatures over the past quarter century.


We like this approach, too, and encourage today's so-called conservatives to utilize free-market economics to help solve these types of problems. Of course, they'll have to start by admitting a problem exists and not burying their head in the sand, hiding behind the "I'm not a scientist, so I don't know" response that seems to be used almost unanimously by them today.



{Our two primary sources for this article were Richard Conniff's story "Blue Sky Thinking" from the August 2009 Smithsonian magazine and a story by Justin Gerdes, a Forbes contributor, written in 2012, which references a 2011 study done by the Harvard Environmental Economics Program. We recommend both articles for additional detail.}




Copyright © 2014-2019.
TheProGunDemocrat.com - All rights reserved.

Home About Us Contact Us